Welcome to Craving Cardboard Shop, where we help revive those cherished childhood memories one card at a time, especially with our extensive collection of baseball cards.
Come browse through our inventory, featuring a massive selection of over 1000 graded slabs (many PSA) and a diverse array of raw cards. We also offer a nice selection of authentic autographed and non-autographed sports memorabilia, ensuring there's something here for every collector—so take a look!
Do you have a card or an entire collection just collecting dust in a box in the basement? Are those stadium bobbleheads and free giveaways piling up with nowhere to display? Perhaps those jerseys are just folded up in a closet instead of being showcased as they should be? We buy cards, whether singles or whole collections, and all types of sports memorabilia.
If you have cards that you want to sell but lack the time or patience, let us take the hassle away and sell them for you. We also accept consignments (email us for terms, conditions, and details).
We offer a wide selection of sports cards, including Football, Basketball, and Baseball Cards from various years for you to choose from. Our inventory features graded cards, raw cards, vintage, and modern options. Additionally, we boast an impressive collection of autographed, numbered, short print, case hits, patch/relic cards. If you're in search of quality autographed memorabilia, we have that too.
Third-Party Graded Cards.
All Graded Cards come from PSA, SGC, BGS, CSG, or select other graders. We never crack and resubmit. The grade you see is the grade you get.
Raw Cards
Ungraded cards are inspected for trimming, alterations, and print defects before listing. We describe condition honestly. Please refer to pics for card condition. If condition not described in description, then card is priced with condition in mind.
If an item arrives damaged or not as described, we make it right. No runaround or games. Refund authorization is always at seller's discretion first. Any returns other than damaged or wrong item that are accepted, return shipping is buyers' responsibility. A refund will be issued once returned item i received and inspected.
If there is a problem, please contact through the "Contact Us" page.
Return and Refund Policy:
Slab: A card that is usually graded and/or authenticated by a professional then sealed in a case to preserve condition
Raw: Term referring to a card that is not graded or encased
Case Hit: Refers to a single card that is considered the best in the case
RPA: Refers to a card that has three elements 1. Rookie Card 2. Has a Patch /Relic 3. Autographed
Below is a standardized raw (ungraded) sports card condition scale widely used by collectors and grading companies. It’s based on PSA/BGS/CGC standards and is best applied to ungraded cards before submission for grading.
Grade-Description-Key Visuals
Mint (MT)Nearly perfect. Sharp corners, centered, no surface issues. Rare, especially vintage.
All corners sharp, clean edges, no wear or discoloration.
Near Mint (NM)Excellent with very minor imperfections. One slight corner flaw or minor centering issue.
One or two corners slightly worn; otherwise sharp and centered.
Excellent-Mint (EX-MT)Light wear visible but presents well. Two or three minor flaws.
Light corner rounding or softening; still sharp and centered.
Excellent (EX)Noticeable wear but still attractive. Soft corners, light scratches, off-centering.
Soft corners, light scratches, possible minor off-centering.
Very Good (VG)Moderate wear throughout. Obvious corner rounding or noticeable creases.
Multiple corners rounded, light creases, possible edge wear.
Good (G)Significant damage. Heavy creases, tears, stains, missing pieces.
Heavy creases, tears, stains, or missing corners/edges.
Fair (F)Severe damage. Major creases, stains, or missing areas.
Major creases, stains, or missing corners/edges.
Poor (P)Extensive damage. Heavy creases, tears, stains, missing pieces.
Heavy creases, tears, stains, or missing corners/edges.